Missouri executes Brian Dorsey for 2006 double homicide after mercy bid backed by 72 correctional officers

The state of Missouri on Tuesday executed Brian Dorsey for the 2006 murders of his cousin, Sarah Bonnie, and her husband, Benjamin Bonnie, after an effort to have his life spared failed in latest days.

Dorsey’s time of loss of life was recorded as 6:11 p.m, the Missouri Division of Corrections mentioned in a information launch. The strategy of execution was deadly injection, Karen Pojmann, a spokesperson for the division, mentioned at a information convention, including it “went easily, no issues.”

The execution of Dorsey, 52, occurred hours after the US Supreme Court docket declined to intervene and a few day after Missouri’s Republican governor denied clemency, rejecting the inmate’s petition – backed by more than 70 correctional officers and others – for a commutation of his sentence to life in jail.

Dorsey and his attorneys cited his regret, his rehabilitation whereas behind bars and his illustration at trial by attorneys who allegedly had a “monetary battle of curiosity” as causes he shouldn’t be put to loss of life. However these arguments had been inadequate to persuade Gov. Mike Parson, who mentioned in an announcement finishing up Dorsey’s sentence “would ship justice and supply closure.”

In a closing written assertion earlier than his execution, Dorsey thanked supporters who advocated on his behalf and apologized to the family members of his victims.

“To all the household and family members I share with Sarah and to all the surviving household and family members of Ben, I’m completely, deeply, overwhelmingly sorry. Phrases can not maintain the simply weight of my guilt and disgrace,” Dorsey mentioned, in keeping with the assertion supplied to CNN by his attorneys. “I nonetheless love you. I by no means needed to harm anybody. I’m sorry I damage them and also you.”

“To my household, pals, and all of people who tried to stop this, I like you! I’m grateful for you,” he mentioned. “I’ve peace in my coronary heart largely due to you and I thanks. To all these on ALL sides of this sentence, I carry no ailing will or anger, solely acceptance and understanding.”

Whereas Dorsey’s petition additionally cited assist from some family who his attorneys mentioned had been additionally associated to the victims, different members of the victims’ households supported the execution, telling CNN in an announcement Dorsey dedicated the “final betrayal” when he killed Sarah Bonnie, his cousin, and her husband Benjamin and left their daughter Jade, then 4 years outdated, within the residence along with her mother and father’ our bodies locked of their bed room.

“Not solely did Jade lose her mother and father however we additionally misplaced a daughter and son, sister and brother, aunt and uncle, and an amazing aunt and nice uncle to so many,” the assertion from Sarah Bonnie’s household learn, partially.

“They had been liked so deeply by anybody that knew them,” it mentioned. “All of those years of ache and struggling we lastly see the sunshine on the finish of the tunnel. Brian will get the justice that Sarah and Ben have deserved for therefore lengthy.”

In his assertion Monday, the governor mentioned the “ache Dorsey delivered to others can by no means be rectified,” and Dorsey’s execution would proceed in keeping with state regulation and as ordered by the Missouri Supreme Court docket.

“Brian Dorsey punished his loving household for serving to him in a time of want,” Parson mentioned. “His cousins invited him into their residence the place he was surrounded by household and pals, then gave him a spot to remain. Dorsey repaid them with cruelty, inhumane violence, and homicide.”

Sufferer’s household sees ‘mild on the finish of the tunnel’

The murders occurred the night time of December 23, 2006. Hours earlier, Dorsey referred to as Sarah asking for assist, in keeping with a historical past of the case included with a ruling by the Missouri Supreme Court docket final month. Two drug sellers had been in his condominium, Dorsey mentioned, and he wanted cash to pay them.

The couple went to Dorsey’s condominium and the drug sellers left. They then took Dorsey again to their residence, the ruling notes, and Dorsey spent the night consuming and taking part in pool with their household and pals.

Later that night time, the ruling mentioned, Dorsey entered their room and fatally shot them with a shotgun at shut vary. Court docket data mentioned Dorsey raped Sarah’s physique. Dorsey’s attorneys argued this stays an allegation; he was by no means charged with and by no means pleaded responsible to rape or sexual assault.

Dorsey was charged with two counts of first-degree homicide and pleaded responsible in March 2008. He was sentenced to loss of life for every homicide, courtroom data present, and his conviction and loss of life sentence had been upheld on enchantment.

The killings had been deeply traumatic for Sarah Bonnie’s household, in keeping with their assertion, noting the our bodies had been found by her mother and father. Within the years after, the household did what they may to maintain the recollections of Sarah and Ben alive, taking their daughter to the cemetery every year to launch balloons.

“We consider all of the issues that she has missed out on throughout her life with out her mother and father. First day of college, college events, college dances, first date, candy sixteen, first boyfriend and highschool commencement,” their assertion mentioned. “All of this was taken from her by a member of the family that proclaimed to like her.”

Jenni Gerhauser, a cousin to each the inmate and Sarah Bonnie, nonetheless, had held out hope Dorsey could be spared. His loss of life is “onerous to return to phrases with,” and the execution was “completely pointless,” she advised CNN’s Laura Coates on Tuesday night time.

“Brian was convicted of a horrible crime. We now have by no means denied that. However Brian will not be the worst of the worst, and a single, horrible night time in his life didn’t justify killing him,” Gerhauser mentioned. “When the … correctional officers despatched that letter (supporting him) to the governor, I felt so validated, as a result of … I can not reconcile this crime with the one convicted for it.”

Inmate’s regret and trial protection warranted mercy, petition argued

Dorsey was deeply remorseful for the murders, his attorneys mentioned. His clemency petition claimed the killings occurred whereas Dorsey was struggling a “drug-induced psychosis and alcohol-induced blackout” after years of substance abuse aimed toward self-medicating power despair.

As proof of his atonement, Dorsey and his attorneys pointed to his spotless disciplinary file and his work as a workers barber; for 11 years, Dorsey minimize the hair of workers on the Potosi Correctional Middle, together with chaplains, wardens and corrections officers – a few of whom wrote to the governor backing his quest for clemency.

“In the event you ask me, if it weren’t for medication, none of this could have occurred,” wrote one whose title, like others, was redacted within the petition for privateness. “The Mr. Dorsey I do know will need to have been out of his thoughts on the time of those murders.”

Moreover, Dorsey’s attorneys contend his sentence was unjust as a result of association by which his trial attorneys had been paid. Each got flat charges of $12,000, which might quantity to only a few {dollars} an hour for the work required in a capital case.

Dorsey’s attorneys allege this created a “monetary battle of curiosity,” which disincentivized work on his case, main the trial attorneys to have him plead responsible with out a assure of a life sentence or adequately investigating. If they’d performed the latter, his present attorneys declare, they could have discovered Dorsey was incapable of the deliberation required for a first-degree murder charge.

Dorsey’s trial attorneys beforehand testified the flat-fee fee didn’t have an effect on their dealing with of the case. One declined to remark when reached by CNN final week, whereas the opposite didn’t reply.

CNN’s John Fritze contributed to this report.

For extra CNN information and newsletters create an account at CNN.com